The threat of stress: key insights for better herd performance
Listen to this article!
In the modern dairy industry, we speak frequently about genetics, nutrition, and technology, but often less about what silently undermines their impact: stress. Whether it manifests in the parlor, the pen, or in unseen hormonal pathways, stress in dairy cattle is both widespread and underestimated. At milkrite | InterPuls, with over 90 years of experience in advancing animal health and milking systems, we know that peak performance is not just about equipment, it's about the cow.
This article marks the first episode in our new series on cow comfort, focused on strategies to elevate cow well-being and farm profitability. Before we dive into specific challenges like heat stress in the next episodes, it’s essential to understand the fundamentals of stress and its profound implications.
The nature of stress in dairy cattle
Stress in cows, much like in humans, is a natural response to perceived threats and it’s often woven into daily life, sometimes subtly, sometimes not.
Common stressors can be:
Physiological:
Heat and humidity
Infections
Pain from lameness or fresh calving injuries
Poor ventilation
Poor feed quality or feed delivery disruptions
Psychological:
Loud, unpredictable handling
Overcrowded housing
Sudden changes in group composition
Negative human interaction
Source: A Review of the Effects of Stress on Dairy Cattle Behaviour, Jurkovich, V.; Hejel, P.; Kovács, L.
Interestingly, these stressors rarely occur in isolation. Their effects are cumulative. A cow that’s recovering from metritis, in a hot, overcrowded pen with poor airflow and little bunk space, is not just uncomfortable; she is physiologically at a disadvantage.
These stressors trigger biological responses that were evolutionarily designed to help animals survive immediate threats, such as predators.
Today’s dairy cows may be far from predators, but the biological stress response remains hardwired. It begins in the brain, travels via the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, and results in the release of stress hormones such as adrenaline and cortisol. These hormones divert energy from "non-essential" functions—like reproduction, immune defense, and milk production—and reroute it toward "survival."
In short bursts, this can be adaptive. But when cows face prolonged or repeated stress, it turns toxic.
Why stress matters more than you think
Chronic stress affects nearly every biological system in the dairy cow. It suppresses immune responses, increases inflammation, disrupts hormone balance, and alters behavior. The result? Increased disease, fertility issues, poor milk yields, and in some cases, reduced longevity.
Take cortisol, for example. Often referred to as the "stress hormone," cortisol helps mobilize energy in the short term. But sustained high cortisol levels:
Suppress immunity, increasing susceptibility to mastitis, metritis, and lameness
Disrupt ovarian function, reducing conception rates
Lower feed intake, worsening energy balance
Impair milk let-down, especially if stress peaks during milking
It’s no exaggeration to say that a stressed cow is an underperforming cow.
What stress looks like on the ground
Stress doesn’t always look dramatic. It’s not just cows running from handlers or refusing to enter the parlor. It can be subtle changes:
Lower rumination time
Fewer steps
Less time lying down
Reduced feed intake
Changes in temperament or avoidance behavior
These behavioral indicators are critical. They’re often the first signs of physiological strain, and they’re detectable with modern monitoring tools. This is where technology and herdsmanship intersect. It’s not just about measuring: it’s about interpreting, responding, and adapting.
The bigger picture: stress, reproduction, and resilience
One area where stress’s impact is especially profound is reproduction. Fertility is sensitive to even small disruptions in hormonal signaling. Cows that are stressed around breeding time have lower conception rates. Those that suffer chronic inflammation from lameness or uterine infections may have ovarian follicles that never fully recover, even after the health issue resolves.
This is where the concept of strain becomes useful. Stress is the external pressure; strain is the cow’s internal response. Some cows handle stress better than others, often due to genetics. But even the most resilient cow will falter under poor conditions. Good genetics cannot compensate for poor management.
What can be done?
No technology is a silver bullet without good herd management practices alongside, so here are some principles we recommend as a foundation:
Design for flow – Parlors should match the cow's size, instincts, and movement patterns. A cow should never feel trapped or surprised.
Train for calm – Quiet, consistent handling reduces fear and resistance. Remember, fear spreads quickly in a herd.
Feed for resilience – Transition diets, consistent feed delivery, and trace mineral support (e.g., vitamin E and chromium) can alter the stress response by improving immune function and lowering blood cortisol concentrations.
Monitor early, act fast – Health monitoring tools can detect changes before clinical signs appear, allowing for preventive action.
Proper management – Maintain appropriate stocking densities, improve human-animal interactions, and provide adequate ventilation and cooling.
Review and refine – Keep records. Analyze health events. Stress builds over time and sometimes the trigger was weeks ago.
Source: A Review of the Effects of Stress on Dairy Cattle Behaviour, Jurkovich, V.; Hejel, P.; Kovács, L.
Managing cow stress is a prerequisite for success. As farms scale and labor challenges rise, reducing stress becomes not just a welfare issue, but a productivity imperative.
By understanding the nature of stress, its impacts, and effective management strategies, farmers can create a more conducive environment for their dairy herds. This holistic approach not only enhances animal welfare but also improves farm productivity and farmer well-being, because comfort isn’t an add-on; it’s the engine of performance.
In our next two articles, we’ll turn our focus to one of the most pressing and measurable stressors on today’s dairy farms: heat stress. Make sure not to miss them.
Sources:
- 4 Tips to improve parlor flow and de-stress milking Turner - Progressive Dairy
- A Review of the Effects of Stress on Dairy Cattle Behaviour Jurkovich, Hejel, Kovács - PubMed Central
- Dairy Cow Stress and Strain: Impacts on Reproduction McCarville, Schlesser, Sterry - University of Wisconsin-Madison Dairy Division of Extension
- Managing Stress in Dairy Cows Villamediana - South Dakota State University Extension
- Minimizing Stress to Enhance Cow Health and Productivity King, DeVries - WCDS Advances in Dairy Technology
- Moo-ving matters: guide to stress-free cattle handling Atkinson - VetTimes
- Strategies to Reduce Stress Polak, Cardoso - University of Maryland Extension